Hugos

Apr. 3rd, 2007 11:44 pm
luckykaa: (Hero)
[personal profile] luckykaa
I got the ballot form for this year's Hugo awards in the post today. 

Looks like I'll have to read 5 books in the next couple of months. 

But I can at least almost form an opinion on Dramatic Presentations. 

The films I had seen were Dead Man's Chest, and V for Vendetta.  Neither of them really deserve the award.  So I have another 3 films to watch. 

Had a quick look at what was avaialable on Virgin's Video on Demand.  The Prestige wasn't available, A Scanner Darkly was too expensive at £3.50.  Children of Men was a whopping 1p, so I decided I could afford that one. 

Interesting film.  Not quite sure I quite get how and why mass infertility caused the social structure to end up the way it has, but the film's really not about that.  So that get's my top vote so far.  I'll have to see the other two before making up my mind. 

Short form, we have a choice of Doctor Who, Doctor Who, Doctor Who, Galactica or Stargate. 

The thing that strikes me about all of these, apart from Girl in the Fireplace, is that they really require knowledge of the entire series. 

The other thing that strikes me is that any show where the hero bursts through a mirror on a horse is just so cool that the other contestants don't stand a chance.

(no subject)

Date: 2007-04-04 06:12 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] gaspode.livejournal.com
You'll be getting a new voting form shortly - don't use that one. There was a cock up. Dead Mans Chest is off - Replaced by Pan's Labrynth ...

The replacement form will explain.

(no subject)

Date: 2007-04-04 09:48 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] vanir.livejournal.com
A Scanner Darkly is a great film, and definitely better than the others you've mentioned. If your Video on Demand is a s good as a DVD rental, I'd go for it.

Hugo V For Vendetta

Date: 2007-04-05 10:16 am (UTC)
From: (Anonymous)
Hi,

Sorry you think V For Vendetta isn't up to scratch for a Hugo. The graphic novel (Alan Moore) on which it was based (and reportedly this is the best screen adaption of a Moore work yet) say its the best one so far. The graphic novel is a kind of '1984' for the late 20th century (as opposed to early to mid 20th century) and is stunning. I have to confess to not seing the film but my colleague Graham on the Science Fact & Science Fiction Concatenation (http://www.concatenation.org) team has (but he has not read the graphic novel) says the film is brilliant. I mention this so as to encourage your blog readers to check this film out.

Of course 'A Scanner Darkly' is probably the hot tip film to win due to the Philip Dick association (and again many say it is the best adaption of a Dick work to screen yet (though I thought 'Screamers' was fairly faithful to the original short story).

Cheers,

Jonathan C.
Page generated Jul. 9th, 2025 08:10 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios